Rye Hotel

3.8 15 reviews
Quality 3.9 Service 3.9 Value 4.0

Reviews (15)

3.8
15 reviews
Excellent
4
Great
5
Average
5
Poor
1
Horrible
0
Businesses on Word of Mouth can't pay to hide reviews. Read more about our review policy here.
EN
emily15 #9 in Reservoir VIC 10 Aug 2017 136 reviews · 12625 points

I have come here quite a few times and the meals have been average, but decent prices. The staff were quick to bring out our meals and there was a nice view of the beach. However, I think Hotel Sorrento is a nicer restaurant to visit.

Quality
3/5
Service
4/5
Value
4/5
MN
turtledoves 04 Aug 2017 174 reviews · 20250 points

I usually visit the Rye Hotel during the quieter months because it is much quicker to be seated. The staff are always lovely and offer help if you need it. However on my most recent visit I ordered the steak and it wasn't cooked how I usually like it, it was a bit under, which was disappointing. But if you are looking for a quick, fast meal then this is a pretty good place to go to. They also have a kids play area, so you can bring the whole family out to dinner.

Quality
3/5
Service
3/5
Value
3/5

Approximate cost: $25

Reply from Rye Hotel 04 Aug 2017

Thank you for taking the time to write a review. We aim to please our customers and I hope that you spoke to a staff member about your steak being under cooked as the Chef would have been more happy to have cooked it more for you? We look forward to seeing you again in the future. Vicki

kerrya7 #1 in Bittern VIC 28 Oct 2013 179 reviews · 21725 points

The best thing about this place is 1) there is a childrens entertainment area and 2) it over looks the beach. Modern looking, clean and a friendly atmosphere. The staff are fabulous and meticulous. Food tastes fantastic and not overly pricey. Can get very busy especially when it is tourist season so booking would be a good idea. A lovely spot to have lunch or dinner.

Quality
4/5
Service
4/5
Value
4/5
KK
Tigerspike #4 in Eltham North VIC 12 Oct 2013 71 reviews · 8710 points

We dined here with a shop-a-docket which stipulated 'buy one main meal get one free' to a maximum of $18.50 free. It wasn't until I was in the line to order that I read that both seniors' meals and meals on the 'special' board were excluded from the deal. We had already a) made the trip to the hotel specially to use the docket and b) decided on our meals before this information was made available. Also not stated on the docket was that only specified meal times and days were included. You have to go there to find out. Too bad if you choose a day which they say (only when you are in line to order) is not included. To avoid customer ill-will they need to be more upfront with their restrictions, rather than just having it printed on the docket that 'conditions apply'.
Even though the senior's meal was cheaper than any of the main meals on either the menu or the specials board, I was not given the option of using it as the free meal. This makes little sense to me, because the hotel would have had to subsidise a regular main meal at a greater cost to itself.
However, we bought the senior's meal as planned, and gave the shop-a-docket to another couple who were yet to order. Strike one.
Another issue we had was that we wanted a glass of moscato, which was on the wine list, but they did not even have an open bottle, let alone a fresh one. We had to order an alternative. The young bar tender was most apologetic. Strike two.
So the meals came out, and they were attractively presented and hot. The eye fillet steak and its vegetables were cooked perfectly, and good value at $15.50. The curry was not too bad. There was a lot of meat in the curry. Pity they served me beef, when I had ordered chicken. Good thing I'm not Hindu. Strike three.

Quality
3/5
Service
3/5
Value
2/5

Approximate cost: $30

SN
shelleyn5 #3 in Tyabb VIC 12 Sep 2013 117 reviews · 11910 points

Rye hotel is a great place to have lunch or dinner! Moder decor with views of the beach over the road. Has a kids area to entertain the kids. A great menu and nice food

Quality
5/5
Service
5/5
Value
5/5
Sim-One #100 in Reservoir VIC 13 Jul 2013 38 reviews · 4845 points

Our second visit to Rye Hotel for dinner. First time was during school Xmas holidays and it was soooo busy, and no one could take a booking apparently when we rang to book, but when we arrived that wasn't the case apparently? Anyhow went again last week - July school holidays this time. We didn't book, but no problem getting a table. The host who seated us was quite friendly and gave us a run down on ordering. Hubby and I both ordered a dips to share and a steak each. My son had a pizza and some fries. The entree was nice and came out quickly, the mains came out promptly too. Our steaks were cooked correctly and quite tasty, they were on a pesto mash which had too much pesto and quite lumpy, plain mash would of been nicer, especially with the sauce choices, the usual mushroom, pepper etc, didn't quite mix with the pesto so strong. Everything came out quickly even though they were also catering a wedding party up the other end of venue. Will go back again, might just try better selection with meal choice based on flavours.

Quality
3/5
Service
3/5
Value
3/5
SW
Renos101 #16 in Lysterfield VIC 07 Apr 2013 36 reviews · 4020 points

Have been here a few times because of their play ground to occupy the kids. Food has on general been pretty good, service needs some attention (missing meals and quite slow) but overall if you have kids it's an easy night out

Quality
4/5
Service
2/5
Value
4/5

Approximate cost: $15-30

ME
Secretshopperalert #2 in Mill Park VIC 09 Mar 2013 513 reviews · 43855 points

I have been here for a family birthday lunch, the food is great the fish and chips i ordered were the best i've had from a pub, everyone elses meals were just as huge as mine. Nice play area for the kids too which is a bonus

Quality
5/5
Service
5/5
Value
5/5
SD
sandrad171 #4 in Carlton VIC 20 Sep 2012 110 reviews · 20625 points

Great pub for the holiday season. Terrific are for the children to play in. Sometimes it can get a little busy and you have to queue up for food but otherwise a good night out.

Quality
5/5
Service
4/5
Value
5/5
sandrar6 #13 in Kilsyth VIC 06 Sep 2012 658 reviews · 66610 points

This Pub in Rye is quite a good one. They have a kids area so they are right and the meals are good.

Quality
4/5
Service
4/5
Value
4/5
JD
jedd #14 in Rosebud VIC 02 Dec 2010 18 reviews · 200 points

The rye pub is fantastic if you have small kids as they have play ground built into the bistro so for once I was able to have an OK meal in relative piece and quite. The food is always ok, about what you can expect from a pub bistro.

Quality
3/5
Service
5/5
Value
5/5

Approximate cost: $25.00

Anonymous 09 Oct 2010

Really liked this place went there for a quick dinner and was quite pleased with the menu and enjoyed the meal I ordered

Quality
4/5
Service
4/5
Value
5/5
MB
MirjanaB #134 in Sunbury VIC 03 Aug 2010 19 reviews · 220 points

Just had a meal there over the weekend and it was actaully really good. the serving of the roast pork my parents had could have been a bit bigger and offer more on the plate. but the parma i had was great. good service, the place never changes :)

Quality
5/5
Service
5/5
Value
4/5

Approximate cost: $19.00

C
444 30 Jul 2010 1 review · 200 points

We were greeted promptly on arrival. We enjoyed a lovely meal & the staff were very pleasant & friendly.The atmosphere is relaxed & warm.

Quality
4/5
Service
4/5
Value
3/5

Approximate cost: $24

AM
anitam3 #76 in Doncaster East VIC 04 Jul 2010 18 reviews · 200 points

We usually always go to this hotel when we are in Rye, it is nice and clean has a playground for the grandchildren to play. The food is usually always great, but lately it has not been to great but still good, They need to check the quality of food that they send out to the customer as one lady was quite upset about the sausages that she got and sent it back. It looked very dried like it had been cooked and then reheated, i would have done the same. on a good note they are offering crepes cooked in front of you and they are great.

Quality
4/5
Service
4/5
Value
4/5

Approximate cost: $68.90

Details

Need a job done?

Post a job and get up to 3 free quotes from local businesses.

Post a job

Business owners

Want more customers? The first step to success is creating a free listing.

Get a professional looking profile with access to our marketplace.

Register free